Posts

Is 0.999... = 1? (spoiler alert: no it is not)

You may have encountered the popular claim that \( 0.999... = 1 \), where the three dots signify that the decimal continues forever. This is a somewhat weird claim, since it would mean that mathematics is broken. There should be no way for two different numbers to have the same value. What makes it weirder is that this is quite popular claim. I've even seen mathematicians say that it's true! But is it though? One popular proof is to first denote \( S = 0.999...\) and then multiply by \(10\) to get \( 10S = 9.999...\) and subtract \( S \) from it, to get  \( 10S - S = 9.000...\) and finally dividing by \(9\) yields  \( S = 1.000... = 1 \) and we see that  \(0.999... = 1\)! However, there's a problem. This short derivation is not strictly speaking correct. It is veeeery close to being correct, and to see why let's look at finite decimals first. Let's say that \(S = 0.999\) (note that this is not the same as \(S = 0.999...\) ). Let's do the same trick as ...

Is 0.999... = 1? (spoiler alert: no it is not)

You may have encountered the popular claim that \( 0.999... = 1 \), where the three dots signify that the decimal continues forever. This is a somewhat weird claim, since it would mean that mathematics is broken. There should be no way for two different numbers to have the same value. What makes it weirder is that this is quite popular claim. I've even seen mathematicians say that it's true! But is it though? One popular proof is to first denote \( S = 0.999...\) and then multiply by \(10\) to get \( 10S = 9.999...\) and subtract \( S \) from it, to get  \( 10S - S = 9.000...\) and finally dividing by \(9\) yields  \( S = 1.000... = 1 \) and we see that  \(0.999... = 1\)! However, there's a problem. This short derivation is not strictly speaking correct. It is veeeery close to being correct, and to see why let's look at finite decimals first. Let's say that \(S = 0.999\) (note that this is not the same as \(S = 0.999...\) ). Let's do the same trick as ...

The year 2019 in optics and photonics

Image
Another year, another review. 2019 was quite a wild year for me, and whew, what a decade it has been! It's hard to imagine that at the beginning of the decade, I was still in high school. In chronological order, starting from 2010: I graduated from high school, served in the army, moved across the country, got my BSc, met five Nobel laureates, started a scicomm platform, got my MSc, moved abroad for work, moved back, got my PhD, got married, moved again across the country, and got a postdoc position. I don't think there will be another decade quite like this one for me! What was your year/decade like? Share in the comments! The winner of this years OSA photography contest, by Dr. Pascale Müller and Prof. Dr. Dan Curticapean: the cross section of a bean, imaged with a scanning electron microscope and digitally colored. Anyway, let's get to the sciencey stuff; here are the news that caught my eye from the past year: Nobel prize in physics This years Nobel prize...

Do we live in a simulation? Probably not.

Image
A while back I came across the article: The Lowest-Bid Universe , where the idea of whether we live in a simulation is examined. The premise of the text is that if this really is the case, then we should lodge complaints of our own reality. Because, apparently, the reality we live in is not that well made. The article starts by superficially mentioning some of the wilder ideas in physics, and then moves on to a "more philosophically motivated" idea that the reality as we experience it is the product of an experiment or a simulation. The standard motivation behind this is to argue that even if only a few civilizations evolve so far that they can produce simulations of whole universes, they inevitably will do a large number of them. Therefore, if there are a large number of simulated realities, it is very likely that our reality is also simulated. Then the writer concludes that if this is truly the case, then our simulation is poorly built. Why would he say so? Becau...

Blog is still alive!

Image
Dang it, I just realized that I haven't updated the blog in over half a year. Oops.  The blog is speaking to you. The last few months have been hectic as hell, and in the beginning of the year I was busy writing my PhD thesis. I got a severe case of "blargh, I never want to write anything again" because, well, I kind of overdid it. Not to brag (as if), but my thesis ended up containing enough material to cover three or four average theses in physics. Oops. Although it was really challenging to write something like that, it was totally worth it. I got my PhD right before the summer vacation; with the highest possible grade might I add (okay, now I am bragging). Also, at the end of the summer I moved across Finland and started a job as a postdoc at Tampere University, yay! Now I am working on things I'm familiar with (coherence of light) and stuff I'm not so familiar with (metamaterials). This research direction seems really interesting, and I wil...

Forced correlations & In search of lost rationality, part 2.

Image
As promised, I'm back for some more lost rationality! And ranting. Yeah, mostly ranting. But before I go there, I'll lay out the research that this rant is related to. This one was about temporal coherence, where we look at correlations between different points in time instead of space. To measure those correlations, you need a device such as a  Michelson interferometer  where you split the incoming light to two, delay one of the copies, and then recombine them. This simple setup is sufficient only for some special cases, and measuring the correct correlations is way more complicated. There actually isn't a general method to do that, modern detectors are far too slow! Let's just say that if you need to measure the temporal coherence of a pulse train, then one way to do it is to isolate individual pulses and measure them with a  FROG  (yes, that is a real scientific instrument) and then study their correlations from the measured data. Anyhow, if you have a...

The year 2018 in optics and photonics

Image
It's that time of the year again, the time to look back on what was accomplished. I couldn't find the time or the energy to write this sooner, and I kind of left this to the last minute. But well, here it is now, the photonics news that really caught my eye this year: OSA Photo Contest winner Here is the photo that won this years annual OSA Photo Contest!  Shot by Tobias Tieß from Leibniz-IPHT, Germany, the photo features a glass cup filled with fluoresciing liquid and a UV-laser is coupled into the handle of the cup. Quite nice effect, I must say. The rest of the contestants can be found here . Nobel prize The Nobel prize in physics was awarded "for groundbreaking inventions in the field of laser physics," To Donna Strickland, Gerad Mourou and Arthur Ashkin. I made a whole post on this, which you can find here for more info. SI system redefinition The SI system underwent a major overhaul! Or to be more precise, it was decided that it will be o...

Le Grand K announces retirement, at last

Image
Starting from 1889 and scheduled to become emeritus (emerita?) sometime in 2019, the International Prototype Kilogram (also known as Le Grand K) had a service of 130 years. Which is a remarkably long time for a standard of measurement based on a metallic cylinder. The change is rather massive (pun intended), because it affects every SI-system unit. However, the biggest change is not the kilogram, but the fact that some of the old SI units had a dependence on measured values. The new definition relates the base units to constants of nature, which will be redefined as being exact. The speed of light is a good example of setting some constant to be exact. We used to measure it's value, which leads to experimental error. But then in the 15th General Conference on Weights and Measures in 1975 it was decided to set it at exactly 299 792 458 meters per second . This also allowed us to define the meter in a very precise way, by establishing some temporal yardstick. Simil...

Quantum mechanics is broken

Image
Quantum mechanics, the brainchild of some of our greatest scientific minds, is broken. Some may object to this, since the theory is one of the most successful ones we have ever had. Indeed, it gives correct results, but that doesn't mean everything is okay. Let me illustrate with an analogy. Imagine you are driving along and suddenly the check engine light turns on (or whatever indicator your car has). But everything seems to be working fine, so you just keep on driving, although the on-board analytics is trying to show that something is wrong. And you just keep on driving, hoping that it doesn't blow up. You can't know how terribly wrong things are before you take the car apart and look inside. I am in no way saying that there is necessarily something wrong in the results of the theory. What I am saying is that although we have every indication that there is something wrong with it, we keep on using it. We've been ignoring the quantum check engine lig...

The Nobel prize in physics 2018: light all the way

Image
As you probably know, the 2018 Nobel prize in physics went to optics and photonics. I cannot say I am surprised, since a lot of the physics Nobel prizes are awarded to this area, either directly or indirectly. It's still nice to see that the people who really deserve recognition are finally getting it. But what is their research really about, and why should we care? Let's start with Arhur Ashkin, who at the age of 96 years, is the oldest Nobel Laureate ever. Ashkin received one half of the prize “for the optical tweezers and their application to biological systems”. Optical tweezers are exactly what they sound like, a tool used to trap and manipulate minuscule things. The tweezers were born from the observation that a dielectric particle tends to move towards the highest intensity in a beam of light. So if the particle you are trapping moves to the edge of the beam, a restoring force will move it back towards the center. This force can be explained for Rayleigh s...

Is it possible to make a laser out of wood?

Image
Wood is a precious material. It has been used for thousands of years as fuel, in construction, for tools and weapons, as well as for furniture and paper. It is also important for biochemistry in the production of purified cellulose and its derivatives, such as cellophane and cellulose acetate. Wood has unarguably been the most important raw material that allowed civilizations to flourish and it will probably remain that way. But quite recently the usefulness of wood has expanded to a completely new area: photonics and optics. When you think about it, it sounds improbable, or even down right stupid to use wood as a material in optical physics, but that's really what has been going on! Let me be clear, this is not the type of wood you would traditionally use, but chemically treated so that it transmits light. The process is simple in principle, you just soak some wood in a chemical that dissolves lignin. Then you take the delignified wood and add epoxy to it, and voila! You...

Arrow of time - reversed or not?

Image
I wrote some weeks ago about the basic concepts behind entropy and the arrow of time . It also conveniently served as test of MathJax . If you have a blog or website where you want to show some equations, you can apply MathJax with a short string of html code, and voila, nice clean LaTeX typesetting becomes available! Okay, enough advertising and let's get on with it. The two main reasons I wrote about entropy last time, is because 1. it is one of the most fascinating concepts in all of physics and 2. there are some fairly recent studies I wish to write about, and one needs to understand some basics before I go deeper into those. There was this one study that was circulated widely in popular science channels, which got hyped into the form: "scientists reversed the arrow of time!" Spoiler alert, no they didn't. I'm not saying that what the group did wasn't seriously cool and a great advancement, it's just that they didn't do what it sai...

Laser awesomeness - The European XFEL

Image
Lasers are awesome, and I guess most people would agree since they have become so common. Anyone can buy a laser pointer with pocket change, and laser shows are used as attractions at night clubs. Blu-ray discs got their name from the type of lasers they are recorded and played with, and almost all production lines utilize lasers at some point. You can even get a car with laser headlights ! But you know what kind of lasers are the most awesomest? The really big and powerful ones, and it doesn't get much bigger or more powerful than the European X-ray free electron laser, or European XFEL for short. European XFEL is an incredible research facility housing one of the most ridiculous lasers ever made by human kind. It's a humongous device, stretching over a length of 3.4 kilometers underground, and it's construction cost is an estimated 1.22 billion euros. The operation of the device sounds like it's taken straight from some sci-fi show. First, on the ...

How large is infinity?

Image
If you are like most people, then you have probably heard children arguing over some kid thing. Have you ever been astonished how easily they resort to infinity? It's like these kids don't even know how large it really is! But how large is infinity? Let's start looking into it with some actual numbers that you can write down in some form. The first really big and easy to understand number is googol . You can google it, googol is a real thing, and Google is actually a misspelling of googol. (Fun fact: the study of very large numbers is called googology.) Googol is simply \(10^{100}\). That's 1 followed by a hundred zeros, so yeah, it's quite a large number. One way to illustrate the size of googol is to compare the mass of the electron, which is \(10^{-31}\) kg, to the estimated mass of the universe, about \(10^{50}\) or \(10^{60}\) kg. If you take one googol of electrons, their mass will be up to \(10^{19}\) times larger than the mass of the whole un...

The many problems of time travel

Image
Time travel is a popular concept in works of fantasy, with many different flavors. In the Back to the Future trilogy, Doc Brown built a time machine out of a DeLorean just because he could. In Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban, Hermione Granger uses a time-turner  so she could study every subject in Hogwarts, and even Superman turns back time to undo the death of Lois Lane. Seems like Superman really is quite super. But scientifically speaking, how much sense does time travel actually make? Let's start from the most obvious type of time travel: forward in time. Clearly we are all automatically traveling towards future time by default, since we age and seasons shift and whatever. But the interesting thing is that according to the theory of relativity, it is possible to slow down the passage of time for yourself, while everything else around you continues to age normally. This effect is called time dilation , and it is an important effect in the universes dynamics....

Entropy and the arrow of time

Image
When you whisk an egg and leave it alone, why doesn't the egg white and yolk separate on their own? If you light a fire, why does it keep burning? And why do we perceive that time never changes it's direction? All of these questions are answered by a single concept in physics: entropy. Simply put, entropy is a measure of the microscopic disorder of a system, and the second law of thermodynamics says that it can only increase or stay constant in a closed system. And all of this is just simple statistics. Let's put this in more concrete terms with a simple example: we flip three identical coins and record the outcome. First of all, what does this have to do with anything? In thermodynamics, we are interested in the energy of the studied system. That energy is made up of all of the individual energy states of the particles that make up the said system. The two sides of a coin represent the possible states of a two level system, which makes it quite a popular example. ...